We who preach the gospel must not think of ourselves as public relations agents sent to establish good will between Christ and the world. We must not imagine ourselves commissioned to make Christ acceptable to big business, the press, the world of sports or modern education. We are not diplomats but prophets, and our message is not a compromise but an ultimatum. A.W. Tozer
Therefore let God-inspired Scripture decide between us; and on whichever side be found doctrines in harmony with the word of God, in favor of that side will be cast the vote of truth. --Basil of Caesarea
Once you learn to discern, there's no going back. You will begin to spot the lie everywhere it appears.

I thank Christ Jesus our Lord, who has strengthened me, because He considered me faithful, putting me into service. 1 Timothy 1:12

Monday, December 19, 2016

ARGH!!!!


Musicians just can’t leave traditional Christian hymns alone.  They just have to abuse them to make their own money off of them!  And why oh why do church music leaders kow-tow to them by using their stuff?!?!?!  (Oh, that’s right — with the abused version you can manufacture more emotion and get more sound out of the band!)

The latest case in point is one we sang yesterday (I saw the copyright so I know it’s a few years old but it was a first for me).  While the the traditional hymn is great for congregational singing, the added chorus was not easy for congregational singing, and the repetition of the last line at the end, and the “oh oh oh” demonstrates that it is just a “radio song” and should stay there on the radio! (I’d prefer it stayed nowhere!)

Here’s the song my “rant” is about.

"Hark The Herald Angels Sing / King Of Heaven"

Hark the herald angels sing 
Glory to the newborn King 
Peace on earth and mercy mild 
God and sinners reconciled 
Joyful, all ye nations rise 
Join the triumph of the skies 
With angelic host proclaim 
Christ is born in Bethlehem 
Hark the herald angels sing 
Glory to the newborn King 

Hail the heav'n born Prince of Peace 
Hail the Son of Righteousness 
Light and life to all He brings 
Risen with healing in His wings 
Mild He lays His glory by 
Born that man no more may die 
Born to raise the sons of earth 
Born to give them second birth 
Hark the herald angels sing 
Glory to the newborn King 

King of heaven come down 
King of heaven come now 
Let Your glory reign 
Shining like the day 
King of heaven come 

King of heaven rise up 
Who can stand against us 
You are strong to save 
In Your mighty name 
King of heaven come 

Oh oh oh 

Christ by highest heav'n adored 
Christ the everlasting Lord 
Late in time behold Him come 
Offspring of a virgin's womb 
Mild He lays His glory by 
Born that man no more may die 
Born to raise the sons of earth 
Born to give them second birth 
Hark the herald angels sing 
Glory to the newborn King 

King of heaven come 
King of heaven come 
King of heaven come 
King of heaven come

by Paul Baloche

Discernment isn’t just about watching for doctrinal problems or abuse of Scripture.  It should also be about protecting from emotional manipulation of the congregation, and about not spending church money to support a musician who had no imagination of his own so he has to steal from old authors and “juice them up.”  Why are we supporting these musicians with royalties when the original is free!!!

PLEASE, PLEASE music/song leaders — don’t do this to your congregations!

Friday, December 16, 2016

About the Genealogies of Jesus


Christmas is the time for false claims against Scripture by atheists, claims of paganism by legalistic Christians, and really claims against just about anything you can imagine in regards to the Faith.  

I’ve written articles about Christmas in the past: 1) debunking the claim that Jeremiah 10:2-5 is about Christmas trees, 2) that we can “plunder the Egyptians” for the good, and 3) examining evidence for the date of Jesus’ birth.  This time I want to answer the claim that the two genealogies of Jesus, in Matthew and Luke, are contradictory.

Throughout my Christian life I had always heard that Matthew gives Joseph’s genealogy while Luke gives Mary’s.  Over the recent years I’ve read other contrived explanations, including that Matthew gives a royal or legal genealogy while Luke gives a biological genealogy.  The problem with all this is that it doesn’t work — Matthew and Luke are both genealogies of Joseph. 

The modern hoops theologians go through to fix an apparent contradiction in the genealogies overlook the real case that Eusebius explained 1700 years ago!

Heli and Jacob, who are both called Joseph’s father, were half brothers with the same mother, Estha. 

Matthan (descended from Solomon and named in Matthew’s list) was Estha’s first husband and they had Jacob.  Melchi (descended from Nathan, and named in Luke’s list) was her second husband and they had Heli.

According to the information Eusebius found in his research, Heli died childless and, under the Levirate marriage laws, Jacob took Heli’s wife and had Joseph. Ergo, Joseph was the biological son of Jacob, but the legal son of Heli.  

Notice that Matthew uses the term “begot” for Joseph’s physical descent. Luke doesn’t use that term, rather he just says “the son of.”

Eusebius cited historical information for these details.  This chart, from Dr. Paul L. Maier’s translation of Eusebius’ Church History, gives a visual presentation of the relationships between the parties:
So forget all the ideas of men who never read Eusebius and are just trying to figure it all out — trust the first Church historian and the research he provided.  There is absolutely no contradiction in the genealogies of Jesus.


Merry Christmas!

Thursday, December 15, 2016

Random Aberrations, Apostasies, and Heresies

At the end of every year I go back over all my old posts to determine their status.  If the information is obsolete, then the article is deleted.  With posts which include links to articles (as in all my “Random…” posts), I check every link to see if they are still good; paragraphs with dead links are deleted.  If too many links are gone, I just delete the entire article; however if some of the links are still good and have what I consider necessary information, I transfer the link to a post in my “Reference Blog.”  You can imagine how much time this takes!  I no longer have any article from 2007, which was my first year blogging, and I have, so far, finished my review up to February 2012. 

Well during this past few days working on the project I got to thinking about why my ministry began and what its focus should be.  As I have previous noted, my first apologetics efforts were trying to reach Mormons with the truth.  Later I began the same thing with Jehovah’s Witnesses.  As time went by I began teaching classes about the cults and how to reach the members of these groups with the truth; in other words I was equipping other Christians with the information they needed to defend their own faith and to plant seeds with cult members.

My ministry has always had three primary functions:  
Proclaiming Truth 
Equipping the Saints
Exposing False Teachings

Over the years my primary focus had been “equipping the saints” who would seek help with understanding cults, help dealing with cult members at their doors, and even general information about understanding Scripture. However, while reviewing my blog I got to thinking that it seems that my primary focus has become exposing false teachings.  While this is important, I think my primary focus should be equipping the saints.  Yes, equipping and exposing both include proclaiming truth, but the better equipped the saints are with the truth, the more readily they can discern the false teachings that come their way.

Part of the reason my thoughts drifted this way is that in so many of my “Random” posts the same teachers and/or groups kept coming up over and over again.  I thought, well we know by now that these are terrible teachers/groups, so anything more is just redundant.

Anyway, I decided to concentrate less on exposing the false teachings of these well-known people and groups, and concentrate more on equipping others with information to counter such false teachings.  Therefore, there will be fewer “RAAH” posts and they will be used to cover important issues or warnings about new false teachers, etc.  I also hope to post more thought-provoking quotes from solid teachers, more examinations of false teachings (such as getting busy on my review of New Age Bible Versions ), and addressing claims from unbelievers against Christians and how to respond, etc. This will most likely mean less frequent postings as more work is required to prepare such articles!  (Random collections of GOOD stuff will continue as much as I find stuff, because these are items for equipping!)

Now, let’s look at the latest collection of links — after all, I already did the work putting them together so I may as well clean out my collection before embarking on the new journey!

The continuing saga of Clayton Jennings.

Teachers of false spiritual warfare include normally sound Tony Evans.

Steven Furtick is a weapon of Satan — contrary to his claims.

Lou Engle, a leader in the New Apostolic Reformation, seems to think he’s the next Billy Graham.

For those who still think the Catholic teaching of “The Immaculate Conception” is about Jesus, Doug Evans has a good lesson for you.

I wonder what the Pope would say about this?  I think such pandering to Islam is atrocious.

Fred Butler continues his review of heretic Hugh Ross’ book, Navigating Genesis.

The poor state of what “Christians” believe; I wonder how many of these are really Catholics? I doubt if any of these people are truly born again.

Scientology is good example of how cults operate.

Hymns in the good old days.

Entertaining the goats at Bethel Redding, et al.

(The graphic at the beginning of this article was developed and provided to me by one of the followers of this blog.)

Tuesday, December 13, 2016

Dietrich Bonhoeffer — Not Biblically Sound


In my last “RAAH” post I included link to the article, “The Troubling Truth About Bonhoeffer’s Theology.”  In the comment section I noted that I had previously written an article exposing some of Bonhoeffer’s false teaching but that I had received so much “hate mail” that I finally just deleted it.  One of the commenters suggested I repost it.

I dug into my file of hard copies I make of all my blog articles and I found the original.  It is a fairly short article, bearing the same title I am using for this post.  Except for the paragraph explaining what led me to writing it, the following is my original post from 18  June 2008, and following it  are some recommended articles for more information about Bonhoeffer’s false teachings.

=============

Dietrich Bonhoeffer was a German theologian who participated in the resistance movement against Hitler, and he was hanged for treason for taking part in an assassination attempt.  He was also known for helping Jews.  So Bonhoeffer had some very good character qualities, but does that make him theologically sound as a teacher?

To understand Bonhoeffer’s beliefs and teachings I will cite just a few items from his book, Christ the Center:

So if we speak of Jesus Christ as God, we may not speak of him as the representative of an idea of God who possesses the properties of omniscience and omnipotence (there is no such thing as this abstract divine nature!).

In His flesh, too, was the law that is contrary to God’s will.  He was not the perfectly good man. … The assertion of the sinlessness of Jesus fails if it has in mind observable acts of Jesus.  His deeds are done in the likeness of flesh.  They are not sinless, but ambiguous.  One can and should see good and bad in them.

About the tomb and Jesus’ resurrection he says:  Empty or not empty, it remains a stumbling block.  We are not sure of its historicity.  The Bible itself reveals the stumbling block in showing how hard it was to prove that the disciples had not perhaps stolen the body.  Even here we cannot evade the realm of ambiguity.

He called the virgin birth a “hypothesis” and said, It is both historically and dogmatically questionable.  The biblical evidence for it is uncertain. 

Bonhoeffer, in this one book, demonstrates a very low view of Scripture, denies the divinity of Christ, denies the virgin birth, denies Christ was sinless, and denies the Resurrection!  With these heretical teachings, why do Christians think he is such a great teacher?  Perhaps because his writings make them feel “spiritual”?

According to David Becker in The Christian News (6/5/00), Bonhoeffer “espoused a religionless Christianity, and expressed doubt about God as a working hypothesis.  He was father of the so-called ‘death of God’ fad of a few years ago.  …he consistently had a low view of the Bible, considering a lot of it myth.”  

Many Christians tend to have favorite teachers they read and are invested in, yet they refuse to use discernment to determine if their teachers are biblically sound.  So much of this is the fault of our church leadership who fail to warn their flocks about wolves and even go so far as to promote them in their “Bible” studies and small group meetings.  I have personally seen the use of Beth Moore, Henry Blackaby, Rick Warren, and Bruce Wilkinson, as well as many of their ilk promoted by church leadership.

Let’s be more discerning about who we allow to teach us about things of Christ and the Christian faith.  Too many wolves are among the sheep.

==============

For articles which go much more in depth as to the false teachings of Bonhoeffer, I can point you to the following:

Dietrich Bonhoeffer – spirit of antichrist? Should he be quoted by Christians?


Book review of Bonhoeffer’s “The Cost of Discipleship” by Gary Gilley.  Not in-depth, but makes a point about Bonhoeffer’s false teachings.


While Bonhoeffer had some good teachings, his heretical ideas outweigh them, and Christians shouldn’t be promoting him as a teacher of the Christian faith.

Friday, December 9, 2016

Personal Freedom Outreach Journal

Back in 1999 I was researching Bill Gothard and his Institute for Basic Life Principles.  I first called Christian Research Institute to see if they had any information about Gothard; they didn’t but they had me contact Midwest Christian Outreach apologetics ministry in the Chicago area.  MCO had done a lot of examining Gothard’s teachings and even met with him trying to correct his teachings. They provided me (free!) with all their material on Gothard (including copies of their journal articles) and also suggested I contact Personal Freedom Outreach apologetics ministry in the St. Louis area for their examination of Gothard.

Well, after reading journals from both these ministries, I began subscribing to them.  With PFO I ordered all the back issues!  MCO’s is a good publication, but isn’t as regular due to the other needs of their ministry.  MCO’s journals are also usually not as in-depth, nor do they have as many people writing for it.  There are several issues of the PFO Journal on-line (for various reasons) but MCO is getting all of theirs on-line.

I can’t recommend the PFO Journal highly enough.  You can get the whole set (from 1981) in pdf format on a CD for about $70.  You can get the complete set of six issues examining Beth Moore’s books for $30.

This introduction is because I am going to be citing the latest issue of the PFO Quarterly Journal, which has excellent articles exposing problematic teachings of Andy Stanley and Priscilla Shirer.  The citations I use should give you a wee bit of a taste for this journal, so enjoy — beginning from the article about Andy Stanley’s new book, by Gary E. Gilley:

To Stanley, the church is an evangelistic center in which the focus is on the “unchurched,” as he calls unbelievers.  Stanley’s goal is to attract non-Christians and retain them, even if this means putting new Christians and even unbelievers into positions of ministry and leadership.  A person can even join North Point online, without talking to anyone.  North Point has limited classroom instruction and the teaching of Scripture is consistently belittled throughout the book [Deep and Wide].

Relationships, on the other hand, especially through small groups, are dominant.  These groups, sometimes led by new Christians and apparently even unbelievers, by necessity are not primarily centered on Scripture or even Christ, as biblically understood, but on relationships.  This is hardly the model found in Acts 2:42-43.  Too bad Stanley did not choose the second chapter of Acts, rather than Acts 15, to develop his ecclesiology — or better yet the New Testament epistles which give instruction on why God has created His Church and how He wants it to function. . . .

[T]he student of biblical truth is one who does not seek knowledge for its own sake, or to stake out a position of superiority over others.  The biblical picture is that truth and theology are used by the Holy Spirit to change lives not just fill our heads.  As the Puritan William Ames defined it, “Theology is the knowledge of how to live in the presence of God.”

Deep and Wide offers nothing that has not been said before by seeker-sensitive leaders.  This philosophy of ministry which first gained traction in the 1970s via Robert Schuller and Bill Hybels has radically changed the Church in the Western world.  The unsaved consumer is now king, marketing strategy sets the direction, and pragmatism rules.  The system “works,” at least numerically, for many like Andy Stanley.  But a careful examination of the New Testament leads us to conclude that this is not God’s design for His Church. . . . 

After discussion of Andy Stanley’s claim of a “secret sauce” for church growth, Gilley exposits Biblical teaching as to God’s “secret sauce,” which includes doctrine, the Faith, Truth, and Teaching/instructing.  The Gilley quotes Kevin J. Vanhoozer: “Desire for God without doctrine is blind; doctrine without desire is empty.”  Later Gilley cites Adrian Rogers:  “It is better to be divided by truth than to be united in error.  It is better to speak the truth that hurts and then heals, than falsehood that comforts and then kills.  It is not love and it is not friendship if we fail to declare the whole counsel of God.  It is better to be hated for telling the truth than to be loved for telling a lie. … It’s better to stand alone with the truth than to be strong with a multitude.”

In his summation of his article, Gilley writes, The alternative to sound biblical theology, in which people walk in truth to the glory of God, is walking in deception to the dishonor of God.  Without clear biblical theology, discipleship is not possible.

The article by M. Kurt Goedelman is regarding Priscilla Shirer’s new book, Fervent, which is supposedly a “battle plan” for prayer.  He begins his review with this:

Near the end of the book of Ecclesiastes, the writer says, “Of making many books, there is no end” (12:12).  Today he might have written, “Of making many books on prayer, there is no end.”

A search on the website of Christian Book Distributors for resources on prayer returns a list of nearly 9,300 books — and more than 16,000 total products — available from just this one company.

Many of these books have little biblical substance.  Those that attract the most attention and record the largest sales often are the least biblically sound.  They owe their success to claims that they offer the latest and greatest insight into communicating with God, breaking spiritual traps and “strongholds” caused by the devil, overcoming and eliminating the difficulties of life, or getting the Almighty “on board” with one’s dreams and aspirations. . . .

[Shirer] tells readers that [Fervent] was a fulfillment of a prophetic word spoken to her. . . .

Shirer touts her book as one Satan doesn’t want you to read.  “At the end of the day,” Shirer tells her readers, “the enemy is going to be sorry he ever messed with you.  You’re about to become his worst nightmare a million times over. . . “

I need to break in here for a personal comment:  You can tell Shirer and Beth Moore hang out together because Moore has stated, in her “Believing God” DVD series, that we become Satan’s worst nightmare, and that he will be sorry he ever messed with us!

It appears that Shirer would have her readers believe it is up to us to activate God’s armor and give it power:  

“Through intentional, deliberate, strategic prayer, you grab hold of Jesus and of everything He’s already done on your behalf.  It’s how you tap into the power of heaven and watch it reverberate in your experiences.  It’s a key part of your offensive weaponry against a cunning foe who prowls around and watches for your weaknesses, your vulnerable places, for any opportunity to destroy you.  In prayer you gain your strength — the power to gird yourself with armor that extinguishes every weapon your enemy wields.”

Author Kris Lundgaard disagrees:

“Many people talk about the power of prayer as if our words or will could move God.  The Scriptures say the Spirit is the real power of prayer, giving life, vigor, and strength to our prayer, and making it persuasive to God.  When we can’t drag ourselves out of bed, he enables us to pray with ‘groans that words cannot express’ (Romans 8:26).”

Prayer does relate to the armor of God and to our spiritual warfare, just not in the way Shirer describes.  Pastor and author Mark Hitchcock writes:

“The significance of prayer to spiritual warfare is evident in the very first word of Ephesians 6:18.  The word ‘with’ is a connecting word.  Prayer is vitally connected to the discussion of spiritual warfare and the Christian’s armor in 6:10-17.  Our defense is not to speak to the devil or demons by binding or rebuking them, but to pray to God.  Ephesians 6:18-20 comes right on the heels of eight verses that deal with spiritual warfare and our arsenal of six pieces of armor.  We might say that after describing our spiritual battle dress or what to wear to war, Paul now tells us how to get dressed.  We get dressed for battle in an attitude of prayer.” 

After another paragraph on spiritual warfare, Goedelman then begins to address Shirer’s teachings about forgiveness; after a couple columns of citations and commentary, he writes:

[A]ccording to Shirer, extending forgiveness is “mostly” for us — a concept never stated in Scripture.  Shirer has missed the fact that biblical forgiveness is a transaction.  Repentance must be expressed and forgiveness sought.  Then forgiveness can be extended to the offending person.  As Donald Whitney observes, “biblical forgiveness is never given or required where there is no repentance.”

While Shirer, in her discourse, correctly incorporates God’s forgiveness to us as the basis and mandate for us to forgive others, she fails to understand that God’s forgiveness is conditional — based upon our repentance.  Apart from our repentance, there is no forgiveness of sin.  Divine forgiveness without repentance is Universalism — the belief that everyone with or without repentance will be saved. . . .

So, then, if we cannot extend forgiveness apart from repentance, how do we keep from being, as Paul states in 2 Corinthians 2:11, “outwitted by Satan” and fall victim to “his designs”?  Whitney provides the healthy and biblical course to follow when a Christian wants to forgive, but the one who has offended refuses to seek forgiveness:

“What Christians should always do, as Jesus exemplified in His prayer, is to be ready to forgive.  And then, when forgiveness is sought, forgiveness can be extended.  Yes, we ought to release our sinful bitterness and hatred whether the offender ever seeks forgiveness.  Some equate this decision with forgiveness itself.  In reality though, this is only getting ready, being willing to forgive.  Then if the offender repents, we are prepared to complete the process by saying, ‘I forgive you.’ The one who announces forgiveness where it hasn’t been sought not only discounts the importance of repentance, he also misunderstands the requirement of Scripture.  But the one who is not willing to forgive is contradicting the Scripture and, for the moment at least, is putting the reality of his salvation to the test.” . . . .

Excluding the Psalms, there are 650 prayers recorded in Scripture.  They are all worthy to be used as prayer prompters, remembering that prayer is a personal matter of the heart.  Jay Adams reminds us:

“Prayer is not a bag of techniques, not learning the right formula, possessing some magic charm, or tacking on an open-sesame type password like ‘in Jesus name.’  It is not a matter of going through proper rituals, nor agonizing before God for long periods of time or anything of the sort.  No, the essential conditions to fulfill have to do with your heart. … In essence, effective prayer is a matter of the heart.”

No matter how perfect a “battle plan” or “strategy” we outline for prayer, if our heart condition is not right, then our prayers are ineffective and wasted.  Scripture tells us what makes up the condition of a “right heart.”  We can pray effectively — or fervently — when we approach God with an obedient heart (1 John 3:22), a forgiving heart (Mark 11:25), an undoubting heart (James 1:6), a broken or contrite heart (Psalm 51:17), an undivided heart (Jeremiah 29:13), a faithful heart (John 15:7), and a yielded heart (Romans 8:26).  These seven conditions do not constitute an exhaustive list but they do provide the basics of the heart attitude and spiritual temperament of the one who desires a fervent prayer life. . . . 

[W]e are certainly grateful for any teacher or any publication that encourages believers to pray more or establish a discipline of daily prayer.  However, prayer should never be seen as an exercise in becoming Satan’s “worst nightmare a million times over.”  The Lord’s Prayer provides a more comprehensive model for prayer.  In it we learn that prayer is first of all a relationship.  We also learn that prayer is to change us as we confess our sins and bow before His glory.  We also find that it is not done to get our will done, but to submit to His will.  There are certainly great mysteries in prayer.  These mysteries are both theological and philosophical.  Prayer is our way as believers to express our total dependence on God.  We also remember that we pray because we are commanded to pray.  To the undiscerning, Priscilla Shirer and her Fervent book misses these truths while overselling and overpromising.

Well, you can see that in reviewing both books the authors of the articles provide the biblical teachings against the teachings of the authors of the books.  This is the normal process with all articles in The Quarterly Journal.  

In addition to main articles, the QJ has an editorial page, a couple pages of news updates in the religious realm, and a book review on the back page.  You couldn’t go wrong by subscribing to this publication and learning solid teaching!

Thursday, December 8, 2016

Random Aberrations, Apostasies, and Heresies

Looking at my collection of links today, it was hard to believe it has only been a week since my last “RAAH” post — so many things in the world of false teachings!  And this is just the highlights!!!  So hold on to your hats.

A perfect example of the false teachings of Rick Warren.  The man is downright dangerous!

The Clayton Jennings saga demonstrates so much that is wrong with today’s fluffy church.  Multiple sex partners have come forward, and Jennings is blowing things off as being “a long time ago.”

The heretical book “The Shack” is soon to be released as a movie.  Please tell your friends not to enrich those who promote heresy.  The Shack is pure heresy, and no one claiming the name of Christ should be reading it.

I continue to be surprised at what goes on in what are supposed to be “churches.”  But I’m NOT surprised to see the connection with Bethel Redding!

Oh goody — A conference for women, led by heretics and false teachers.  No wonder women are more and more the victims of false teachings.

The Watchman Fellowship has produced a new profile, this time on heretic Bart D. Ehrman.

The Troubling Truth About Bonhoeffer’s Theology.   And yet Christians continue to praise him as an excellent teacher!

Fake Christian Jim Wallis.

Contending for the faith on social media.

Doug Evans has handed out his “False Teacher of the Year” award to Rick Joyner.  Excellent choice!

An interesting lecture by Ken Ham, exposing the many theologians who give up the Bible as their authority and place “science” as their ultimate authority.

It never ceases to amaze me the way false prophets continue to propagate and actually get people to listen to them!!  These wolves pop up so quickly that it’s impossible to keep up with them.  Just use discernment, knowing that anyone claiming a direct word from God is a liar.  (Notice this link also shows two “churches” — Revolution Church and Potential Church — who apostatize using movie productions to teach)

Remember Todd White, the guy who teaches you to read yourself into the Bible?  Well has turned the gospel upside down.  It’s no wonder that he wears his hair like a member of the Rastafarian religion — he has no understanding of the Christian faith.

Speaking of Todd White, he and his church Bethel Redding are 100% frauds and tools of Satan.

Another testimony by someone who was with Adventures in Missions and The World Race.


Andy Stanley doesn’t care about the birth of Christ!